What Is a Medical Billing Clearinghouse and Do You Need One?

Table of Contents

A clearinghouse is a bridge between the software and insurer that sorts the claims against the format each payer wants, delivers claims, and tells what are the problems. The medical billing clearing house is neither the one that bills nor the PMS. Clearinghouse in medical billing receives the claims from the practice management software, checks whether they are accurate or not, changes the format as per payer rules, and delivers them electronically. 

What a Healthcare Clearinghouse Is?

Clearinghouse is a covered entity under the HIPAA law (45 CFR 160.103) and it changes the nonstandard data into standard format. Healthcare clearinghouses are covered entities in their own right alongside health plans and providers. Clearinghouse signs a business associate agreement with the practice and it can manage the patient health information on the behalf of your practice. 

How a Claim Moves Through a Clearinghouse

The claims move in a batch, one batch contains many claims for many payers. These steps show the journey of one batch of claims. 

  1. The practice management software creates the claim but how is the claim created? It is created as an EDI 837 file. For professional claims, it is 837P and 837I for institutional claims. Claims go in batches and every batch has several claims. 
  2. The clearinghouse keeps an eye on the claims and does the edits and this process is often called claim scrubbing. What it entails is checking the format according to the HIPAA rules, valid identifiers, and payer-specific rules. 
  3. The claims that clearinghouse finds alright are sent to the payers. If the payer does not have an electronic connection, clearinghouse prints and sends it via mails as a paper claim.
  4. The payers answer with acknowledgement reports. The 999 speaks for the whole file: it cleared the syntax checks, passed with errors, or was rejected. The 277CA speaks for each claim inside an accepted file: accepted for processing, or rejected with a reason. If the 999 rejects the file, no 277CA is produced and the whole batch has to be corrected and resent.
  5. The payer adjudicates the claim and returns an EDI 835, the electronic remittance advice (ERA), showing what was paid, reduced or denied and why.
  6. The clearinghouse sends the 835 back into your software for payment posting. 

From step 5 onwards, the claim is denied. Before step 5, it is a claim rejection.

Claim Rejection vs Claim Denial

Rejection and denial are different but what is the thing that differentiates them? The payer does not process the rejected claim because it never enters the payer’s adjudication system. The claim can be rejected by the clearinghouse edits, by the payer’s 999, or by the payer’s 277CA. The claim that fails the clearinghouse edit is rejected. So, there is no need to appeal or work on the rejected claim. You just make corrections and then send the claim again. A claim denial is the claim processed and not paid but sent back. The reasons for denial are present on the 835 file with claim adjustment code. This claim needs either a corrected claim or an appeal, depending on the reason. 

Taking care of the timely filing window is also important otherwise rejections are converted into denials. If the rejected claim is not corrected and sent back in the timely filing window, the practice can run out of the timely filing window, and a claim filed after that window is denied. What is first-pass acceptance? It is the share of claims the clearinghouses and the payer’s front end accept when the claim is sent for the first time. It measures the formatting and whether the claim is complete or not.

Clean claim rate or first-pass payment rate, is the share paid on the first adjudication. It is a measure of accurate coding and the quality of billing. A high acceptance rate with a low payment rate means that the claims are well-formed and wrong. 

Direct Submission vs Clearinghouse

Medical practices can send the claims directly to payers without the clearinghouse being part of the process. This is called direct submission. There are many payers that accept direct submissions without a clearinghouse. Every direct connection, though, comes with its own EDI enrollment, its own file rules and its own set of acknowledgement reports to read. ERA and EFT enrollments are a separate thing. 

Under the Administrative Simplification Compliance Act, Medicare does not pay for paper claims unless there is an exception. Some exceptions are: if there are fewer than ten full-time-equivalent employees in a physician practice or there is an institutional provider who has less than 25 full-time equivalent employees. These are some cases where Medicare pays for paper claims.  

Medical practices can manage one or two high-volume payers for direct submission otherwise it is laborious administrative work. If practices are dealing with a mixed payer list, this is where clearinghouses play their role. It replaces several enrollments, connections and report formats with one.

What Clearinghouse Does Not Do

  • It is not a medical coder and it does not code, it can flag a missing or invalid modifier field, not a wrong modifier.
  • It does not tell whether the procedure was needed or not, it does not check the coverage policy. 
  • It does not check or help in getting prior authorization.
  • It does not appeal or rework denials. A denial on the 835 is delivered to you and resolving it is denial management work.
  • It does not verify the coverage details and verify benefits of the patients unless you buy and use the 270/271 eligibility transaction.
  • It does not reach every payer and some payers connect to certain clearinghouses. If a payer is missing from the network means paper claims or a second clearinghouse.

Do You Need a Medical Billing Clearinghouse?

Your situation Usually Why
You bill several payers from your own practice management software Yes One connection and one report format instead of many
You bill Medicare only, or close to it Maybe not Direct submission to your contractor is free and electronic
Your PMS or EHR bundles a clearinghouse You already have one Find out which vendor it is and what the fallback is
You outsource billing Use the billing company’s Ask which clearinghouse, who holds the EDI enrollments, and what happens at contract end
Under 10 FTEs and still on paper Still worth it Paper waits 29 days instead of 14 and gives you no acknowledgment reports

Medical practices that bill several payers in-house need a clearinghouse because the alternative is difficult to maintain as they have to maintain each payer connection themselves. A Medicare-only practice can go direct at no cost. A practice that outsources billing does not need its own contract. The billing company’s medical billing services submit claims through its own clearinghouse connections, while the practice’s practice management software still builds the 837 and receives the 835 as before. 

What to Ask Before You Sign

  • Which payers are on your network, and which still accept paper claims?
  • How are payer-specific edits maintained, and who maintains them?
  • Do the 999, 277CA and 835 land inside the software or there is a separate portal?
  • Who manages the ERA and EFT enrollment with each payer?
  • Check the pricing, is it per claim, per provider, per month or bundled with software?
  • Will you sign a business associate agreement?
  • If we leave, who owns our EDI enrollments and how long does the transition take?

Conclusion

A medical billing clearinghouse checks whether the claims are ready to go to the payers as per their format. If there are problems, the claims are rejected before they are processed by the payer. It catches format and completeness errors before the claim is adjudicated. If a medical practice only submits claims to Medicare, it can submit claims directly. If you outsource billing, ask which clearinghouse they use and what would happen if the clearinghouse stops working. If you want to outsource billing and understand about the clearinghouse, get in touch with our experts. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a clearinghouse the same as a billing company?

No. A clearinghouse moves and checks claim files between your software and payers. A billing company codes, submits, posts payments and works denials, and uses a clearinghouse to do it.

No. HIPAA requires that electronic claims use the standard transaction formats. A clearinghouse is one way to meet that requirement; submitting directly to the payer in the standard format is another.

The 999 answers for the whole file: did it pass syntax checks. The 277CA answers for each claim inside an accepted file: accepted for processing, or rejected with a reason. If the 999 rejects the file, no 277CA is produced.

Yes, but every payer needs a new EDI enrollment under the new submitter, and ERA enrollment moves separately. Plan for a transition period in which claims may go through both.

Jasmine Oliver

Revenue Cycle Management Expert | Content Strategist in Healthcare | MedCare MSO

Jasmin Oliver writes about revenue cycle management, medical billing, and coding compliance. With over 12 years of experience, she turns complex RCM concepts into clear, practical insights that help healthcare providers and billing teams improve accuracy and revenue performance.

Let’s Get in Touch!

Please, fill the form, it won’t take more than 30 seconds

1 Step 1
reCaptcha v3
keyboard_arrow_leftPrevious
Nextkeyboard_arrow_right

Free Revenue Audit

Losing revenue to denials?
Let's find it — free.

See exactly where your practice is leaking revenue. We review 90 days of claims, denials, and aged A/R at no cost.

Request Your Free Demo

🔒 HIPAA-secure. Your information is never shared.

1 Step 1
Let’s Get in Touch

If you’d like to talk to someone now, give us a call at 800-640-6409. ​
To request a call back, just fill out this form. Please let us know your interest so we can be sure to have the best person call you.

reCaptcha v3
keyboard_arrow_leftPrevious
Nextkeyboard_arrow_right